Fasting has become one of the most talked-about approaches to weight loss and health improvement. But there’s a version that’s gaining attention for being more flexible than traditional fasting methods. It’s called dirty fasting, and it might change how you think about intermittent fasting.
What is dirty fasting? Dirty fasting is a modified version of intermittent fasting where you consume small amounts of calories (typically under 100) during your fasting window, rather than consuming zero calories. This approach allows black coffee with cream, diet sodas, sugar-free gum, and other low-calorie items that traditional “clean” fasting would prohibit.
How Does Dirty Fasting Differ from Clean Fasting?
Clean fasting means consuming absolutely nothing except water, black coffee, or plain tea during your fasting window. Your body stays in a complete fasted state with zero caloric intake.
Dirty fasting takes a more relaxed approach. You can have:
- Coffee with a splash of milk or cream
- Diet soft drinks and zero-calorie beverages
- Sugar-free gum
- Bone broth (in small amounts)
- Supplements and vitamins
- Artificial sweeteners
The key difference is that dirty fasting prioritises making the fasting period easier to stick to, even if it means slightly compromising the metabolic benefits.
Does Dirty Fasting Break Your Fast?
Technically, yes. Any caloric intake triggers some metabolic response in your body. When you consume even small amounts of calories, your body begins producing insulin and shifts away from the deep fasted state that clean fasting creates.
Research shows that consuming as little as 50 calories can stimulate insulin production and interrupt autophagy, the cellular cleaning process that happens during extended fasting periods. However, the insulin response from small amounts of calories is minimal compared to eating a full meal.
The practical answer is that dirty fasting keeps you in a semi-fasted state. You won’t get 100% of the benefits of clean fasting, but you’ll get more benefits than not fasting at all.
9 Steps To Shed 5–10kg in 6 Weeks
While spending as little as 90 minutes per week in the gym!
Includes an exercise plan, nutrition plan, and 20+ tips and tricks.
Without dead boring diets that are like watching paint dry
Without getting results at a snails pace
Gym or at home version
What Are the Benefits of Dirty Fasting?
Dirty fasting offers several advantages that make it appealing for people who struggle with traditional fasting:
1. Easier to Maintain Long-Term
The biggest benefit is adherence. Studies on weight loss consistently show that the best diet is the one you can actually stick to. If adding 30 calories of cream to your morning coffee means you’ll continue fasting for months instead of quitting after two weeks, that’s a worthwhile trade-off.
2. Reduced Hunger and Cravings
A small amount of bone broth or coffee with cream can significantly reduce hunger pangs during your fasting window. This makes it easier to reach your eating window without breaking down and consuming a large meal.
3. Still Promotes Weight Loss
Even with small caloric intake during fasting, you’re still creating a calorie deficit over 24 hours. Research on intermittent fasting shows that the primary driver of weight loss is the overall reduction in daily caloric intake, not necessarily the depth of the fasted state.
4. Maintains Energy Levels
Some people experience fatigue, headaches, or difficulty concentrating during strict fasting. Small amounts of calories can help maintain blood sugar stability and energy without significantly impacting fat burning.
What Are the Downsides of Dirty Fasting?
Dirty fasting isn’t perfect. Here are the main drawbacks:
1. Reduced Autophagy
Autophagy is the process where your cells clean out damaged components and regenerate. This process peaks during extended fasting periods with zero caloric intake. Any calories, even minimal amounts, can slow or interrupt this process.
2. Slower Fat Burning
When you consume calories, even small amounts, your body shifts from burning stored fat to processing the incoming energy. This means you’ll burn less body fat during your fasting window compared to clean fasting.
3. Potential for Calorie Creep
The flexibility of dirty fasting can become a problem. What starts as 30 calories of cream in your coffee can gradually increase to 50, then 100, then 200. Before you know it, you’re consuming enough calories to significantly impact your results.
4. Artificial Sweeteners May Increase Cravings
Research on artificial sweeteners shows mixed results. Some studies suggest they can increase sugar cravings and appetite, making it harder to stick to your eating window when it arrives.
Who Should Try Dirty Fasting?
Dirty fasting works best for specific groups of people:
- Beginners to intermittent fasting who need a gentler introduction
- People who have failed at clean fasting due to hunger or discomfort
- Those prioritising weight loss over other fasting benefits like autophagy
- Individuals with demanding schedules who need sustained energy during fasting periods
- People taking medications that require small amounts of food
Who Should Stick with Clean Fasting?
Clean fasting is better for:
- People seeking maximum autophagy benefits for cellular health
- Those who want optimal fat burning during fasting windows
- Individuals who don’t struggle with hunger during fasting periods
- People focused on metabolic health improvements beyond weight loss
Common Dirty Fasting Mistakes to Avoid
Mistake 1: Consuming Too Many Calories
Keep your fasting window intake under 50-100 calories maximum. Going beyond this significantly impacts your fasted state and reduces benefits.
Mistake 2: Using It as an Excuse to Snack
Dirty fasting doesn’t mean constant grazing on low-calorie foods. Limit your caloric intake to one or two small additions, like cream in your coffee.
Mistake 3: Choosing Poor Quality Additions
If you’re going to consume calories during fasting, make them count. Bone broth provides minerals and collagen. Heavy cream provides fat for satiety. Diet soft drinks provide nothing beneficial.
Mistake 4: Not Tracking What You Consume
It’s easy to underestimate calories. A “splash” of cream can quickly become 50-100 calories if you’re not measuring. Track everything during your fasting window.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I have coffee with milk during dirty fasting?
Yes, coffee with a small amount of milk (around 30ml or less) is acceptable during dirty fasting. This typically adds 15-20 calories, which stays within the dirty fasting guidelines. However, this will trigger a small insulin response and reduce some fasting benefits.
Will diet soft drinks break my fast?
Diet soft drinks contain zero calories, so technically they don’t break a fast. However, artificial sweeteners may trigger an insulin response in some people and can increase cravings. If weight loss is your primary goal and diet drinks help you stick to fasting, they’re acceptable for dirty fasting.
How many calories can I have during dirty fasting?
Most experts recommend staying under 50-100 calories during your fasting window. The lower you keep it, the more benefits you’ll retain. Going over 100 calories significantly impacts your fasted state.
Is dirty fasting effective for weight loss?
Yes, dirty fasting can be effective for weight loss. The primary mechanism of weight loss with intermittent fasting is creating a calorie deficit, which dirty fasting still achieves. Studies show that adherence matters more than perfection, so if dirty fasting helps you stick to your eating schedule, it will work.
Can I exercise while dirty fasting?
Yes, you can exercise during dirty fasting. The small amount of calories consumed may actually help maintain energy levels during workouts. However, intense training might require more substantial nutrition, so adjust based on your performance and recovery.
Does bone broth break a fast?
Bone broth contains calories (typically 30-50 per cup), so it does technically break a fast. However, it’s one of the better options for dirty fasting because it provides minerals, electrolytes, and collagen while keeping calories relatively low.
The Bottom Line on Dirty Fasting
Dirty fasting represents a middle ground between traditional eating patterns and strict intermittent fasting. It won’t give you 100% of the benefits that clean fasting provides, but it offers a more sustainable approach for many people.
The research is clear on one point: consistency beats perfection. If dirty fasting helps you maintain an intermittent fasting schedule for months or years, you’ll see better results than someone who does perfect clean fasting for two weeks before giving up.
Your choice between clean and dirty fasting should depend on your goals, lifestyle, and what you can maintain long-term. If you’re primarily focused on weight loss and find strict fasting too difficult, dirty fasting is a solid option. If you’re seeking maximum autophagy and metabolic benefits, clean fasting is the better choice.
The most important factor isn’t whether you choose clean or dirty fasting. It’s whether you can stick to your chosen approach consistently enough to see real results. Start with what feels manageable, track your progress, and adjust based on what works for your body and lifestyle.
