Nutrition

What are the healthiest eggs to eat?

In this article

Mother Earth News tested eggs from 14 pasture raised flocks across the United States and compared them to USDA data for commercial eggs.

Eggs as food are hard to beat for the price, and pasture raised eggs are the healthiest type you can buy. Compared with standard supermarket eggs, they tend to carry more omega 3 fatty acid, vitamin E, vitamin A and vitamin D, because the hens forage outside instead of living on grain alone. If you want the most nutrition from your breakfast, start there.

That said, every egg is a good choice. A regular supermarket egg still delivers about 6 grams of protein, vitamin B12, choline for brain health and only around 70 calories. The gap between egg types comes down to how the chickens live and what they eat, and that is what the rest of this guide explains.

Are Pasture Raised Eggs Actually Better?

In terms of nutrient density, yes. Researchers at Pennsylvania State University compared eggs from pasture raised hens with eggs from hens kept on conventional feed. The pasture raised eggs had about twice as much vitamin E and more than double the omega 3 fatty acids, plus around 38 percent more vitamin A.

An earlier 2003 study reported even bigger differences. It found that one pasture raised egg contained roughly twice the omega 3 fat, three times the vitamin D, four times the vitamin E and seven times the beta carotene (β-Carotene) of eggs from hens raised on standard feed.

Mother Earth News tested eggs from 14 pasture raised flocks across the United States and compared them with United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) data for commercial eggs. The pasture raised eggs had one third less cholesterol, one quarter less saturated fat, two thirds more vitamin A, twice the omega 3 fatty acids, three times the vitamin E and seven times the beta carotene. This was an informal test rather than a controlled trial, so treat the exact figures as a guide, not a guarantee. The direction of the results matches the university research.

The reason is diet. Pasture raised hens roam outside and eat grass, bugs, worms and seeds alongside their regular feed. Commercial hens eat grain, soy and corn in indoor facilities. What the chicken eats goes straight into the egg, which is why the yolk of a pastured egg is often a deeper orange.

What Do All Those Labels Mean?

Walking through the egg aisle can feel confusing. Here is what each label generally means.

  1. Pasture raised means hens spend much of their time outdoors on open ground. Under the Certified Humane standard, that means at least 108 square feet of outdoor space per bird, with hens eating grass, bugs and feed. These eggs usually have the best nutrition.
  2. Free range means hens have some outdoor access, but with less space than pasture raised birds. The nutrition varies depending on how much time they actually spend outside.
  3. Cage free means hens live inside barns without cages and have no guaranteed outdoor access. The nutrition is similar to conventional eggs.
  4. Organic means hens eat organic feed grown without synthetic pesticides, and they must have some outdoor access. Organic food standards cover how the hens are fed and housed, but they do not require a diet rich in forage, so the nutrient profile can still resemble a conventional egg.
  5. Omega 3 enriched means hens eat feed with flaxseed or fish oil added. These eggs can contain several times more omega 3 fats than conventional eggs.
  6. Conventional means hens live in cages indoors and eat standard grain feed.

The USDA does not treat cage free or free range labels as a promise of better nutrition. What matters is the hens’ diet and whether they actually get outside to forage.

Are Brown Eggs Healthier Than White Eggs?

No. Shell colour has no effect on nutrition. Brown and white eggs contain the same protein, vitamins and minerals when the hens eat the same diet.

The colour comes from the breed of chicken. Hens with brown feathers generally lay brown eggs, and hens with white feathers lay white eggs. Some breeds even lay blue or green eggs.

Brown eggs often cost more because brown feathered hens tend to be larger and eat more food. That higher cost for farmers gets passed on to you, so you are paying for the breed and not for extra nutrition.

Research from Hendrix Genetics tested 58 eggs from white and brown laying hens fed the same diet. It found no difference in protein content, fat content, moisture or mineral levels between the two colours.

How Many Eggs Can You Eat Per Day?

Most healthy people can eat one to two eggs per day without problems. Large studies that followed hundreds of thousands of people over many years have found that eating up to one egg per day does not raise heart disease risk in healthy adults.

The American Heart Association says one whole egg per day, or two for older adults with healthy cholesterol, can fit into a heart healthy eating pattern. The Mayo Clinic says most healthy people can eat up to seven eggs per week without affecting heart health.

If you have high cholesterol, diabetes or heart disease, talk to your doctor first. Some guidance suggests limiting eggs to three or four per week for people with diabetes or existing heart conditions.

The confusion around eggs and heart health comes from cholesterol. One large egg yolk contains about 186 mg. But research now shows that the cholesterol you eat has less impact on blood cholesterol than saturated fat and trans fat do. An egg contains only about 1.5 grams of saturated fat and no trans fat.

Your liver makes most of the cholesterol in your body, and the cholesterol in food affects people differently based on genetics and overall diet. What you eat alongside the eggs matters too. Eggs with vegetables and wholegrain toast are a different proposition from eggs with bacon and sausages.

What Is The Healthiest Way To Cook Eggs?

Poached and boiled eggs are the healthiest options. They add no extra fat or calories and keep more nutrients intact than most other methods.

Cooking time matters. USDA analysis found that eggs baked for 40 minutes lost up to 61 percent of their vitamin D, while eggs fried or boiled for shorter times kept 82 to 88 percent.

Here is how common methods compare.

  1. Poached eggs cook in simmering water with no added fat. The yolk stays runny, which preserves more nutrients. About 70 calories per egg.
  2. Soft boiled eggs cook in their shells for about 6 minutes. The runny yolk keeps more nutrients than a firm one. About 70 calories per egg.
  3. A hard boiled egg cooks for 10 minutes or longer. It is easy to prepare ahead and eat on the go. About 78 calories per egg.
  4. Scrambled eggs often need butter or oil and can lose some B vitamins from longer cooking. About 90 to 100 calories per egg depending on added fats.
  5. A fried egg needs oil or butter to cook. Using olive oil or avocado oil is a better choice than butter. About 90 calories per egg.

For any method, use lower heat and shorter cooking times. High heat and long cooking destroy more nutrients and create more oxidised cholesterol.

If you scramble or fry eggs, add vegetables such as spinach, tomatoes or mushrooms. This boosts fibre and vitamins without many extra calories.

Should You Eat The Yolk?

Yes. The yolk holds most of the nutrition in an egg.

The egg white provides protein but not much else. The yolk supplies vitamin D, vitamin A, vitamin E, vitamin B12, iron, choline and the omega 3 fats. It also contains the lutein and zeaxanthin that help protect your eyes from age related damage.

Eating only whites means missing those nutrients. If you want to eat more eggs but worry about cholesterol, mix one whole egg with one or two whites. You keep some of the yolk nutrition and add extra protein.

What About Specialty Eggs?

Omega 3 enriched eggs are a good alternative if you cannot find or afford pasture raised eggs. One study found they contained 39 percent less of the omega 6 fatty acid fraction and about five times more omega 3 fats than conventional eggs. That matters because modern diets already supply plenty of omega 6, so shifting the balance towards omega 3 is the useful part.

The omega 3 in these eggs comes from flaxseed or fish oil in the hens’ feed. Fish oil provides DHA and EPA, which your body uses more directly than the ALA omega 3 found in flaxseed.

Check the label for specific amounts of DHA and EPA if omega 3 content matters to you.

How Much Do Different Eggs Cost?

Egg prices vary by type and by retailer. In Australia, expect to pay roughly these amounts per dozen, though supply and brand can move them.

  1. Conventional caged eggs run about $4 to $6 AUD
  2. Cage free eggs run about $6 to $8 AUD
  3. Free range eggs run about $7 to $10 AUD
  4. Organic eggs run about $9 to $12 AUD
  5. Pasture raised eggs run about $10 to $14 AUD

Pasture raised eggs cost more because the hens need more land, fencing and care. Farmers also lose more birds to predators and weather, and those costs show up in the price.

Think about what the extra money buys. A pasture raised egg with more vitamin E and omega 3 can be worth a few extra dollars a week, especially if eggs are a daily protein source for you.

Quick Tips For Buying The Healthiest Eggs

  1. Look for pasture raised eggs if your budget allows. They have the best overall nutrition.
  2. Choose omega 3 enriched eggs as your second best option. They cost less than pasture raised but still have a better fat profile.
  3. Ignore shell colour. Brown, white, blue and green eggs have the same nutrition when hens eat the same diet.
  4. Check for third party certifications such as Certified Humane on pasture raised eggs. This helps confirm the hens actually get outdoor access.
  5. Buy the freshest eggs you can find. Check the date on the carton and store them in the coldest part of your fridge.

How Should You Store And Handle Eggs?

Even the healthiest eggs are only as good as the way you keep them. A few habits protect both nutrition and safety.

  • Keep them cold. Store eggs in the main body of the fridge in their carton, not in the door where the temperature swings. The carton also stops them absorbing strong odours.
  • Cook until the white is set. Runny yolks are fine for most healthy adults, but pregnant women, older adults, young children and anyone with a weakened immune system should cook eggs until both white and yolk are firm.
  • Do not use cracked eggs. If a shell is cracked when you open the carton, discard that egg.
  • Use the float test only as a rough guide. A very fresh egg sinks and lies flat. An older egg stands upright or floats because the air cell inside grows. If in doubt, crack it into a bowl and smell it.
  • Cool boiled eggs quickly. Run a boiled egg under cold water, refrigerate it and eat it within about a week.

Taking care here means the vitamins and healthy fats you paid extra for actually end up on your plate.

FAQ

Which eggs have the most protein? All eggs have about 6 grams of protein regardless of type or colour. Shell colour and farming method do not change protein content in any meaningful way.

Do pasture raised eggs taste different? Many people say pasture raised eggs taste richer and have darker orange yolks. The colour comes from the carotenoids in grass and bugs. Taste also depends on freshness and the hens’ diet.

Are organic eggs healthier than conventional eggs? Organic eggs come from hens fed organic feed without synthetic pesticides. Research shows mixed results on whether organic food of this kind has better nutrition for the egg itself. Pasture raised matters more than organic for nutrient content.

Can you eat eggs every day? Yes. Most healthy adults can eat one to two eggs daily without increasing heart disease risk. People with high cholesterol or diabetes should ask their doctor about the right amount.

What is the difference between free range and pasture raised? Free range hens have some outdoor access but may spend most of their time indoors. Pasture raised hens get far more outdoor space, at least 108 square feet each under the Certified Humane standard, and spend significant time foraging on grass.

Do eggs raise cholesterol? For most people, eating eggs has less effect on blood cholesterol than eating saturated fat and trans fat. Your liver makes most of your cholesterol. Individual responses vary, so people with high cholesterol should monitor their levels.

Why are brown eggs more expensive? Brown eggs cost more because the hens that lay them eat more food. Brown feathered hens tend to be larger breeds. You pay for higher feeding costs, not better nutrition.

Quality protein sources like eggs play a key role in any successful weight management plan. Learn more about how Kelly Clarkson really lost weight through lifestyle changes, or explore how many calories models eat to maintain their physiques. A personal trainer in Elwood can help you build a nutrition strategy that works for your goals.

armstrong author profile (1)

Armstrong Lazenby

Armstrong Lazenby is a BSc (Human Nutrition) registered nutritionist and holds a Bachelor of Science in Exercise Science and a Master of Sports Medicine. A former professional athlete who competed representing Australia for 4 years, Armstrong has held scholarships with the Victorian Institute of Sport, Australian Institute of Sport, and the Olympic Winter Institute of Australia.

Qualifications:
• BSc (Human Nutrition) — Registered Nutritionist
• Bachelor of Science (Exercise Science major)
• Master of Sports Medicine
• Certificate III & IV in Fitness