Weight Loss

Which meal is best to skip for weight loss?

In this article

A 2019 review of 13 studies published in the BMJ found that people who ate breakfast actually gained about 0.5kg less than breakfast skippers.

If you’re going to skip one meal for weight loss, dinner is the one that costs you least. In the United States Department of Agriculture’s analysis of national dietary data, skipping dinner removed the most calories and did the least harm to overall diet quality. Skipping a meal is still a blunt form of calorie restriction, though. Whether it works for you depends on what you eat at the other meals and when you eat them.

In that analysis, skipping dinner cut about 350 calories from a day. Skipping breakfast cut about 252. Dieting advice often treats all three meals as equal, but the data shows they aren’t, and the timing research adds a second layer. When you eat can affect hunger and blood sugar almost as much as what you eat. We’ve coached plenty of clients through this, and we’ll share what holds up in practice as well as in the studies.

Does skipping breakfast help you lose weight?

Not reliably. Skipping breakfast can trim your calories for the day, but it isn’t a shortcut, and for some people it backfires.

A 2019 review of 13 trials published in the BMJ looked at whether eating breakfast helps people lose weight. It found no support for that idea. Breakfast eaters ended up slightly heavier, by around half a kilogram, because they ate more across the day. The same review found no evidence that skipping breakfast produces meaningful weight loss either. The effect was small in both directions, so breakfast is not a weight-loss lever on its own.

The risk is what happens later. Some people who skip breakfast feel their appetite and the hunger hormone ghrelin climb through the afternoon, and they overeat at lunch or dinner. Appetite signals are not always well calibrated. A classic 1950s study of Bengali workers, from the region where the Bengali language is spoken, found that the most sedentary workers actually ate more than lightly active ones. It shows appetite can drift from real energy needs, which is why a plan that depends on willpower alone tends to wobble.

Diet quality matters too. The USDA analysis found skipping breakfast lowered diet quality by 4.3%. People who skip it tend to eat less fruit, fewer whole grains and less dairy, and more empty calories later in the day.

Does skipping dinner help you lose weight?

Yes, it can. Of the three meals, dinner is the cheapest to give up in calories, nutrition and, for many people, hunger.

The USDA data put the saving from skipping dinner at about 350 calories a day, nearly 100 more than skipping breakfast. Diet quality fell by only 2.6%, compared with 4.3% for breakfast. Dinner is also where many people eat their largest meal, and where snacking tends to creep in afterwards, so removing it often removes the evening grazing as well.

A 2013 Israeli trial shows how much timing can matter even when calories are fixed. Women with obesity ate the same 1400 calories a day, split differently. One group had a 700 calorie breakfast, a 500 calorie lunch and a 200 calorie dinner. The other group had a small breakfast and a big dinner. After 12 weeks, the big breakfast group lost more weight, had better fasting glucose and insulin levels and reported feeling less hungry through the day.

A study published in Obesity found that early time restricted eating, with all meals between 8am and 2pm, lowered ghrelin and raised the fullness hormone PYY in the evening. Participants felt less hungry and had less desire to eat once they had stopped eating earlier in the day.

In our own coaching, the clients who do well without dinner are the ones who made it a deliberate choice. They still hit their protein and calorie targets. The ones who struggle are usually skipping it by accident because they got home late and too tired to cook.

Why does the timing of meals matter for weight loss?

Your body handles food differently at different times of day because of your circadian rhythm.

Research from Johns Hopkins and other institutions suggests we process food better in the morning than at night. Insulin works more efficiently earlier in the day, and digesting a meal burns somewhat more energy in the morning. Late-night eating is linked with a greater tendency to store energy as fat.

One study found that eating dinner an hour before bed, rather than four hours before, impaired glucose tolerance the next morning. People who eat more of their calories close to their natural melatonin onset also tend to have higher body fat percentages, and that pattern is associated with a higher body mass index. BMI is a crude measure because it can’t tell muscle from fat, but across large groups it tracks these timing patterns.

That gives some support to the old line about eating breakfast like a king, lunch like a prince and dinner like a pauper. People who eat the bulk of their calories at dinner have a higher risk of obesity and metabolic syndrome.

What happens to your metabolism when you skip meals?

Skipping meals does not speed up your metabolism. What it can do is lower your total intake, and that is what drives weight loss.

Your resting metabolic rate makes up roughly 50% to 70% of the energy you burn each day. The thermic effect of food, the energy used to digest and process what you eat, adds another 5% to 10%. Protein has the highest thermic effect at around 20% to 30%, so 100 calories of protein nets you about 70 to 80. Carbohydrate sits at around 5% to 10% and fat at 0% to 3%.

Researchers at the German Institute of Human Nutrition found that time restricted eating without cutting total calories did not improve metabolic markers or heart health. The benefits seen in earlier intermittent fasting studies were probably down to eating less, not to the clock itself.

That is useful to know. Calories still come first. If skipping dinner helps you eat less overall, you’ll lose weight, and you don’t need elaborate timing rules to do it.

How does intermittent fasting compare to skipping meals?

The two can give similar results. Intermittent fasting simply puts a fixed structure around the skipping.

A year-long trial compared time restricted eating with daily calorie counting. Both groups lost weight, and the difference between them was not significant. People restricting their eating window tended to eat less without counting anything, mostly because they had less time to eat and cut out evening snacks.

The most popular approach is 16/8, where you eat within an 8 hour window and fast for 16. Eating between 10am and 6pm, for example, effectively skips late dinner and after-dinner snacking.

Earlier windows seem to do better than later ones. One study found that eating between 8am and 2pm improved insulin sensitivity, blood pressure and oxidative stress, even without weight loss.

How many calories do you save by skipping each meal?

  1. Skipping dinner saves about 350 calories
  2. Skipping lunch saves about 300 calories
  3. Skipping breakfast saves about 252 calories

These figures come from USDA analysis of what US adults report eating, so they are averages. Your own saving depends on how big your meals usually are.

People do tend to eat more at the next meal after skipping one, but they rarely make up the whole gap. A saving of 250 to 350 calories a day, held for a few weeks, adds up to a real deficit.

What should you do if you want to lose weight by changing your eating schedule?

Shift more of your food to earlier in the day and less to the evening.

  1. Make breakfast your biggest meal, with plenty of protein
  2. Eat a moderate lunch
  3. Eat a smaller dinner at least 3 to 4 hours before bed
  4. Avoid eating after dinner
  5. Set a consistent eating window if you want to try time restricted eating

The plan that works best is the one you can keep doing. Comparisons of popular diets find broadly similar weight loss, with results tracking how closely people stuck to the plan. For a broader look at pacing your efforts, see the fastest way to get in shape.

Pick the version that feels least restrictive. If skipping breakfast is easy for you, try that. If a big breakfast and a small dinner suits your life, do that instead.

How do you skip a meal without wrecking your diet?

Skipping a meal works when protein and total calories are still covered. We’ve coached clients who skip a meal, and that condition is what separates the ones who get results from the ones who feel awful.

One client who regularly got home late asked whether she could have a single protein-rich meal at lunchtime and skip dinner. We said yes, as long as her protein target was met and her calories weren’t too low. If hunger hit in the evening, we suggested a large salad with a light yoghurt and mustard dressing. Another client with measured progress had been skipping lunch to cut calories. On those days she’d have carrot and celery sticks with a little hummus and a boiled egg, or Greek yoghurt with a few blackberries. Both clients kept their results because the meals they did eat were built properly.

Our default is simple. Most people do well on two to three balanced meals a day, each built around a palm-sized serving of protein, a good amount of vegetables and a small handful of carbohydrates. If you skip one meal, make the others bigger versions of the same template rather than filling the gap with snacks. Dieting gets harder when meals become improvised, and hunger is hardest to manage when the remaining meals are low in protein.

Some people should not skip meals at all, including anyone with a history of disordered eating, anyone pregnant or breastfeeding, and anyone on glucose-lowering medication. Speak to a doctor first if any of that applies.

FAQ

Will I lose muscle if I skip dinner?

Not if you eat enough protein across the rest of the day. The standard minimum is 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight, but people who are dieting and training generally do better nearer 1.6 grams per kilogram. Protein at breakfast helps preserve muscle and keeps you full. If you want to know whether 100g of protein is too much, for most adults it isn’t.

Is it bad to go to bed hungry?

Being slightly hungry is fine. Eating close to bedtime impairs glucose metabolism and can disrupt sleep, and late-night eating tends to raise hunger the next morning. If you’re properly hungry rather than mildly peckish, you probably under-ate earlier, so adjust your other meals.

How long does it take to see results from changing meal timing?

Hunger hormones can shift within days. One study saw changes in ghrelin and fullness hormones after just 4 days of early time restricted eating. Weight loss takes longer and depends on your overall deficit. A daily deficit of 500 calories works out to roughly 0.5kg of fat loss a week.

Should I skip the same meal every day?

Consistency helps. Irregular meal timing is linked with a disrupted circadian rhythm and worse metabolic outcomes. Choose a pattern you can keep up most days of the week.

What about eating one meal a day?

It can work, because it creates a large deficit. But the USDA analysis found that skipping several meals does more damage to diet quality, and it’s hard to get enough protein into one sitting. Most nutrition professionals suggest at least two meals spread through the day.

Does coffee count as breaking a fast?

Black coffee has almost no calories and doesn’t trigger a meaningful insulin response, so it doesn’t break a fast in any practical sense. Milk and sugar add calories.

Can I exercise if I skip dinner?

Yes. Many athletes train fasted. A morning session before breakfast is fine. If you train in the evening and skip dinner, make sure you’ve had enough protein and carbohydrate earlier in the day to fuel it.

What if I work night shifts?

The advice to eat early and fast at night may not suit you. Keep your meals consistent relative to your work hours, and eat while you’re awake and fast while you sleep, even if that differs from traditional mealtimes.

Meal timing can shape your results, but protein and total calories decide most of them. If you’d like help setting up nutrition and training together, a personal trainer in Elwood can build a plan around your schedule.

armstrong author profile (1)

Armstrong Lazenby

Armstrong Lazenby is a BSc (Human Nutrition) registered nutritionist and holds a Bachelor of Science in Exercise Science and a Master of Sports Medicine. A former professional athlete who competed representing Australia for 4 years, Armstrong has held scholarships with the Victorian Institute of Sport, Australian Institute of Sport, and the Olympic Winter Institute of Australia.

Qualifications:
• BSc (Human Nutrition) — Registered Nutritionist
• Bachelor of Science (Exercise Science major)
• Master of Sports Medicine
• Certificate III & IV in Fitness