Nutrition

Is it better to cut carbs or fat?

In this article

Most people lose fat well on a deficit of 300 to 500 calories per day.

Is it better to cut carbs or fat for weight loss? Both work. When calories and protein are matched, a low-carbohydrate diet and a low-fat diet produce very similar fat loss over the long term. The better plan is the one you can follow consistently while still feeling good.

Each approach does change your hunger, energy, training and health markers differently. So the more useful question is “which diet fits my life?” Below is what the research says, followed by how we judge a plan in practice, so you can make that call yourself.

What does the research say about low carb vs low fat?

Several large meta analyses have compared low carb and low fat diets head to head, and the findings are consistent.

A 2022 meta analysis published in Frontiers in Nutrition, a journal from the publisher Frontiers Media, pooled data from dozens of trials. It found both diets were equally effective for long term weight loss when total calories were the same. A 2020 meta analysis of 38 studies and 6,499 adults found low carb diets had a slight edge at 6 to 12 months, with about 1.3 kg more weight loss on average. Over time, that gap shrank.

A 2006 study published in JAMA followed 447 people. Low carb dieters lost 3.3 kg more than low fat dieters at 6 months. By 12 months the difference had dropped to just 1.0 kg and was no longer statistically significant.

A 2024 network meta analysis ranked low carb as the top performing approach, with a P score of 0.8994. Even so, results varied with individual factors, especially how well someone stuck to the plan.

The takeaway: when protein and calories are equal, fat loss is almost the same on both diets. In our experience with clients, we don’t see a fat loss edge for low carb over balanced carbs. Pick the approach that feels easiest to follow.

Do you lose weight faster on low carb?

In the first 1 to 2 weeks, yes. People on low carb diets often drop weight faster at the start, but a big chunk of that early loss is water, not fat.

Your body stores carbohydrate as glycogen in your muscles and liver, and every gram of glycogen holds roughly 3 grams of water. When you cut carbs, those stores empty and the water goes with them. It looks great on the scale, but it returns as soon as you eat carbs again.

After the first few weeks, the rate of real fat loss between the two approaches evens out. A 2015 meta analysis in PLOS One found stricter carb restriction led to about 0.91 kg more weight loss than low fat diets, a small difference.

If you want a quick number on the scale to stay motivated early on, low carb delivers. Just remember the long game is fat loss, not water loss.

How does cutting fat help you lose weight?

Fat is the most energy dense nutrient you eat. It packs 9 calories of food energy per gram, while carbs and protein each contain 4. A small amount of fat adds up fast.

A ribeye, a rich primal cut taken from the rib section of the animal, cooked in oil and butter can contain over 60 grams of fat. That is more than 500 calories from fat alone in one meal. Cutting back on cheese, butter, cream, fatty meats and oils can save you hundreds of calories a day without shrinking the food on your plate.

Don’t go too low, though. Aim to stay above roughly 35 to 50 grams of fat per day. Your body needs fat to absorb vitamins A, D, E and K, to produce hormones and to keep your brain working properly. Most people eat well above that minimum, so there is room to trim.

A simple swap works well. Instead of ribeye every night, rotate in leaner cuts like top sirloin a few times a week. Each swap can cut a meaningful amount of saturated fat from the meal, and you still get a satisfying steak.

Be careful with packaged “diet food” marketed as low fat. Manufacturers often add sugar or starch to keep the taste, so the calories can end up close to the full fat version. Check the label before assuming it saves you anything.

How does cutting carbs help you lose weight?

Cutting carbs works mainly because you end up eating fewer calories, often without thinking about it. Bread, pasta, rice, cereal and sugary snacks are easy to overeat. Removing them pushes you toward protein and vegetables, which are harder to overeat.

Low carb diets also tend to lower insulin levels. Insulin signals your body to store energy, so when it drops, stored fat is easier to access for fuel. This is one reason people on a low-carbohydrate diet often report feeling less hungry between meals.

The 2020 meta analysis of 38 studies found low carb diets improved HDL cholesterol by about 0.05 mmol/L and lowered triglycerides, both good signs for heart health. The same analysis found they raised low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol and total cholesterol, which is worth watching.

Low fat diets tend to improve LDL numbers more. So the better choice for health markers depends on what your blood work looks like right now. Talk to your doctor if cholesterol is a concern.

Does it matter where your calories come from?

Yes and no. For pure fat loss, total calories matter most. But the source of those calories affects how full you feel and how much energy your body spends digesting them.

This is where protein stands out. The thermic effect of protein is about 20% to 30%, so of every 100 calories of protein you eat, your body uses 20 to 30 just to process it. Carbs sit at about 5% to 10% and fat at 0% to 3%.

That means 100 calories of chicken breast and 100 calories of butter are not equal. You net roughly 70 to 80 calories from the protein and 97 to 100 from the fat.

Studies suggest that moving from a low protein to a high protein diet raises your daily calorie burn by about 4% to 5%. That is a modest but real boost that adds up over months.

It’s one reason both approaches work better when protein stays high. Aim for about 1.6 to 2.0 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day, or roughly 0.8 grams per pound. That is also why we set protein first with every client, whatever the carb and fat split ends up being.

Which diet is easier to stick with long term?

This is the question that decides results. A meta analysis of popular diets found every diet performed about equally poorly for long term weight loss on average. But when researchers sorted people by how closely they followed their plan, they found a straight line: the better the adherence, the more weight lost, regardless of the diet.

Many people lose a meaningful amount of weight at some point in their lives. The problem is keeping it off, and that usually happens because the diet was treated as a temporary event instead of a lasting change. Even celebrity transformations tend to come down to routine more than tricks, as you can see in how Kim Kardashian lost her weight.

So ask yourself: can you do this for the rest of your life?

If you love bread and pasta, giving them up will be miserable and low carb will be hard to maintain. If you enjoy meat, cheese and rich foods, a low fat diet will feel like punishment. Choose the form of restriction that feels least restrictive to you.

Some people thrive on low carb because they feel less hungry and more focused. Others do better on low fat because they can eat larger portions of rice and potatoes. Neither is wrong. The wrong diet is the one you quit after three weeks.

What about keto vs a standard low fat diet?

Keto takes low carb to the extreme. A standard keto diet limits carbs to about 20 to 50 grams per day, roughly one banana’s worth. That pushes your body into ketosis, where it burns fat for fuel instead of glucose.

Keto can produce faster initial weight loss than a standard low fat diet, largely because of water lost as glycogen empties. Some people also report reduced appetite, which makes eating less easier.

But keto is hard to maintain. It removes most fruit, grains and legumes, and social eating gets complicated. If you fall off the plan, the weight comes back quickly as glycogen and water refill.

A 2024 meta analysis in adolescents found low carb diets produced 2.81 kg more weight loss and a 1.13 greater reduction in body mass index (BMI) compared with other diets. The studies ranged from very low carb to moderate low carb, so the results don’t apply only to keto.

We’ve also seen the other direction. One client who came off a keto, high fat approach moved to high protein, moderate carb and lower fat meals, and found it far easier to live with. For most people, a moderate low carb approach of 100 to 150 grams of carbs per day gives much of the benefit without the extreme restriction. You can still eat fruit, some grains and plenty of vegetables.

What should you eat on a low carb diet?

Here are the foods that form the base of a solid low carb eating plan, and a healthy diet of this kind is built on whole foods rather than packaged substitutes.

  1. Meat and poultry like chicken breast, turkey, lean beef and pork
  2. Fish and seafood like salmon, tuna, prawns and cod
  3. Eggs prepared any way you like
  4. Non starchy vegetables like spinach, broccoli, capsicum, zucchini and cauliflower
  5. Nuts and seeds like almonds, walnuts, chia seeds and flaxseeds
  6. Fats like olive oil and avocado, with coconut oil in small amounts because it is high in saturated fat
  7. Full fat dairy like cheese, Greek yoghurt and butter in moderate amounts
  8. Berries like strawberries, blueberries and raspberries in small portions

Foods to reduce or avoid on low carb include white bread, pasta, rice, cereal, sugary drinks, lollies, cakes and most processed snacks.

What should you eat on a low fat diet?

A low fat diet focuses on high volume, lower calorie foods. Here is what that looks like.

  1. Lean proteins like chicken breast, white fish, turkey mince and egg whites
  2. Complex carbs like oats, brown rice, sweet potato, quinoa and whole grain bread
  3. Fruits like bananas, apples, oranges and berries
  4. Vegetables of all kinds, especially leafy greens
  5. Legumes like lentils, chickpeas, black beans and kidney beans
  6. Low fat dairy like skim milk, low fat yoghurt and cottage cheese
  7. Whole grains like pasta, rice and cereals with minimal added sugar

Foods to reduce on low fat include fried foods, butter, cream, full fat cheese, fatty cuts of meat, coconut oil and processed baked goods.

How many calories should you cut to lose fat?

Most people lose fat well on a deficit of 300 to 500 calories per day. That works out to about 0.25 to 0.5 kilograms of fat loss per week, a safe and sustainable pace.

You can create the deficit through diet alone, or combine diet with more movement. Walking 7,000 to 12,000 steps per day is one of the easiest ways to raise your calorie burn without intense exercise.

A 30 minute daily walk adds roughly 3,000 steps and burns about 100 to 200 extra calories for most people. Over a month, that can add up to close to an extra pound of fat lost.

To find your starting calories, use a free online calculator with your age, weight, height and activity level. Track your food for 1 to 2 weeks, then adjust based on how the scale moves. If your weekly average weight falls by about 0.25 to 0.5 kg, you are in the right zone.

Weigh yourself first thing in the morning after using the bathroom, do it daily and take the weekly average. Don’t react to daily swings. Your weight can bounce 1 to 3 kg in a day from water, food volume and salt.

Does exercise matter for fat loss on either diet?

Exercise burns calories, but its biggest benefit for fat loss isn’t the calories burned in the session. It’s everything else.

Exercise improves insulin sensitivity, reduces inflammation and improves almost every health marker even if the scale doesn’t move. People who lose weight and keep it off for years are far more likely to exercise regularly than those who regain it.

Exercise also sharpens your sensitivity to fullness signals. Research shows active people regulate their appetite better than sedentary people. A study of Bengali workers in the 1950s found sedentary workers actually ate more than lightly or moderately active workers. Once people were active, they naturally matched food intake to energy needs.

Training also matters when the scale seems stuck. Plenty of people end up asking why they’re skinny but still have a lower belly pooch, and the answer is often low muscle and low strength training rather than too much food.

Whether you go low carb or low fat, add resistance training 2 to 4 times per week and aim for regular daily movement. Diet and exercise together beat either one alone.

How much does a typical low carb or low fat diet cost?

Both diets can be done on a budget or get expensive, depending on your food choices.

Low carb diets can cost more because they lean on meat, fish, nuts and avocados. Chicken breast runs around $10 to $14 AUD per kilogram at most supermarkets, while salmon can run $25 to $40 AUD per kilogram.

Low fat diets can be cheaper because they use staples like rice ($3 to $5 AUD per kg), oats ($4 to $6 AUD per kg), lentils ($3 to $5 AUD per kg) and frozen vegetables ($2 to $4 AUD per bag).

Either way, buying in bulk, choosing frozen produce and picking cheaper proteins like eggs ($6 to $8 AUD per dozen), canned tuna ($2 to $3 AUD per can) and chicken thighs instead of breast keeps costs down.

How do you know if your plan is working for you?

Studies tell you what works on average. Your own hunger, energy and training tell you what works for you. We judge every plan the same way: if you’re energised, not overly hungry and training feels okay, keep going. If energy dips or cravings show up, we add carbs around training before changing anything else.

If you’re unsure whether a higher carb, lower fat plan suits you, run a simple two week test:

  1. Hit your protein target first every day.
  2. Stay under your calorie target.
  3. Run a higher carb week, then a lower carb, higher fat week.
  4. Compare hunger, energy, sleep, gym performance and how easy each week was to repeat.

Because calories and protein stay constant, any difference you notice comes from how the plan feels, which is the thing that predicts whether you’ll stick with it.

Some people need to be more careful. For a client with no thyroid, we steer away from very low carbs. Going under roughly 120 grams a day tends to bring fatigue, brain fog and poorer training in that situation. We aim for 150 to 180 grams with high protein and a mild deficit. If you have a medical condition, get personal advice rather than copying someone else’s numbers. A personal trainer in Maribyrnong can help you run this kind of test and adjust it to your training.

FAQ

Can you cut both carbs and fat at the same time?

You can, but be careful. Cut both too far and you won’t have the energy to train, and the diet will feel miserable. Keep protein high and reduce either carbs or fat (or both slightly) until you reach your calorie target. Don’t slash everything at once.

Is low carb bad for your heart?

Not necessarily. Low carb diets tend to improve HDL cholesterol and triglycerides, which are both good for heart health. But they can raise LDL cholesterol in some people. If you have a family history of heart disease or high cholesterol, get your blood work checked regularly and talk to your doctor about which approach fits best.

Will I lose muscle on a low fat diet?

Not if you eat enough protein and do resistance training. Muscle loss while dieting comes from too few calories, too little protein or no strength training, not from low fat eating itself. Aim for 1.6 to 2.0 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight and lift at least 2 to 3 times per week.

How low should I go with carbs on a low carb diet?

Most people see good results between 50 and 150 grams of carbs per day. Under 50 grams puts you in ketosis territory, which works for some people but is hard to maintain. Between 100 and 150 grams is moderate low carb and still allows fruit, some grains and plenty of vegetables.

Do I need to count calories on either diet?

You don’t have to, but it helps. Some people lose weight without tracking by simply cutting certain food groups. If your weight stalls, tracking for a few weeks can show where extra calories are hiding. Food labels can have up to a 20% error, so consistent tracking matters more than perfect accuracy.

Which diet is better for people with diabetes?

Low carb diets can help manage blood sugar because they reduce the glucose entering your bloodstream after meals. A 2009 study found a fructose heavy diet worsened insulin sensitivity, while research on low carb approaches shows improved blood sugar control. If you have diabetes or prediabetes, talk to your doctor before making big changes.

How long does it take to see results on either diet?

You should see measurable fat loss within 2 to 4 weeks on either diet if you keep a consistent calorie deficit. Low carb shows faster results on the scale in week one because of water loss, but actual fat loss speed is similar. Give any diet at least 4 to 8 weeks before judging it.

Can I switch between low carb and low fat?

Yes. Some people rotate between phases of lower carb and lower fat eating based on their energy needs, training schedule or preference. There is no rule that says you must commit to one approach forever. What matters is staying in a calorie deficit for fat loss and keeping protein high, whichever approach you use.

armstrong author profile (1)

Armstrong Lazenby

Armstrong Lazenby is a BSc (Human Nutrition) registered nutritionist and holds a Bachelor of Science in Exercise Science and a Master of Sports Medicine. A former professional athlete who competed representing Australia for 4 years, Armstrong has held scholarships with the Victorian Institute of Sport, Australian Institute of Sport, and the Olympic Winter Institute of Australia.

Qualifications:
• BSc (Human Nutrition) — Registered Nutritionist
• Bachelor of Science (Exercise Science major)
• Master of Sports Medicine
• Certificate III & IV in Fitness